Dauphine

Policy-Development Monopolies: Adverse Consequences and Institutional Responses

La Chaire Recherche

Recherche
Auteur(s) Ken SHOTTS
Type de publication Présentation

We analyze a model of policymaking in which only one actor, e.g., a bureaucratic agency or a well-funded interest group, has the capacity to develop high-quality policy proposals. By virtue of her skills, this actor has an effective monopoly on policy development and thus can craft proposals that are good for herself but provide few benefits to decisionmakers who enact policies. We then examine institutional responses that decisionmakers can use to induce a policy-development monopolist to craft more-appealing proposals: (i) establishing in-house policy development capacity, (ii) delegating authority to an agent who counterbalances the monopolist's preferences, and (iii) fostering competition by policy entrepreneurs with different preferences. We apply our model to a diverse set of contexts, including bureaucratic policymaking in Japan, lobbying in term-limited state legislatures, regulation of banking and financial services, and administrative procedures for rulemaking in U.S. federal bureaucracies.

This paper was presented at the Lunch seminar organised on 20 September 2016

Nos communautés


  • Fondation Paris-Dauphine
  • logo_dauphine_couleurs_edition_0_1.png
  • LOGO_PSL_violet_0.png

Nos partenaires


  • ASFA_Log_CRVB_0.png
  • ENEDIS_RVB_300 dpi_0.png
  • ENGIE_0_0.png
  • LOGO FDJ FIN RVBpetit_0_0.png
  • logo_GROUPE_ADP_cmjn_0.png
  • RTE_logo+signD_CMJN_CS4 - Copie_0.png
  • Le+logotype_0_0.png
  • VINCI Autoroutes_0.png
  • logo_conseil_2009_fr_gris_0.png
  • Logo_CGE-01_0_0.png
  • Cour des Comptes_0_0.png
  • ACPR_0.png
  • Logo_AMF_CMJN_0.png
  • LOGO ARAFER_0.png
  • ARCEP new-court_2.png
  • LOGO ARJEL_1.png
  • CEPS clairs_0.png
  • LOGO_CRE_A_UTILISER-Versionréduite_1.png
  • logo_CSA_0.png
  • Logo ASI_0.png
  • Logo DGAC_quadri_0.png
  • logo_hadopi_2017_0.png
  • DEPARDIEU_LOGO_VECTORISE_0.png
  • frontier_logo_0_0.png
  • LOGO NOIR YLIOS.png
  • oecd_logo_0.png